The title is a tad misleading, and might disappoint viewers expecting the illusion of straight guys experimenting. In truth, the few scenes that play off the theme deal with gay men coming out of the closet and (supposedly) having sex for the first time. It's an intriguing concept that works in the opening scene only, when Joshua Shaw actually does a pretty good job of pretending he's never sucked dick before, taking guidance from Taylor Donovan (a lie of course; he's way too good at it), and then putting on a painful face when he gets fucked. It's fun, but outside of one decent blowjob, the next three scenes don't offer much.