Multi-hyphenate Michael Lucas returns to Fire Island with a new set of East Coast cuties. This time around, Richie Fine is out to land "the great porn star Michael Lucas" (guess who wrote the script) and buddy Chris Bolt wants to get fucked by the biggest dick on the island. Together, these two crazy kids set out to make their dreams come true, but first they stop for a rooftop fourgy with Mitch Ryder and Aaron Tanner. Then Fine checks out a poolside orgy where he hopes to meet his idol. Housemate Alfanso Vega and lover Christopher Young get nasty with a beer bottle. Bolt realizes his goal when he meets Chad Hunt, who steals the show with his massive cock and expert fucking. Fine doesn't get so lucky when he finally hooks up with Lucas. Their scene starts well enough but soon devolves into a simulated rape, with Fine whimpering, crying and begging for mercy as Lucas steps out of character (himself) and begins directing the action. Only then does Boys on Fire stop being a first-rate video with excellent videography and editing (both by Michael Clift) and becomes a harrowing outtake of a scene gone terribly wrong. Clift should have edited this one right out of the movie.