The Collector is a good quality disc with good picture-in-picture graphics and nice colorful scenes. Unfortunately there is a noticeable moire pattern in the picture and a slight pixelation around the edges. The most noticeable flaws are in some brief black and white scenes where the noise is hard to ignore. Carnal Witness is a perfect disc. The colors are very vibrant and gorgeous. The outdoor night scenes are clean and crisp. Both warmly lit and cooler scenes come across with strikingly true colors. This reviewer cannot find a flaw on this disc.