Pillow Talk Fantasies is an exploration of non-traditional sex for tentative newbies. Like Carmen Caliente touching herself under the watchful eye of husband Seth Gamble: "This is something I've kept private. Personal. But the idea of touching myself for him makes me so wet. ... When your reality is hotter than your fantasy, you know you're in love." The scene develops with masturbation as a key element, with Caliente stroking Gamble to climax.

Isabella Nice introduces an anal sex segment by saying, "Jack has been asking me to try anal sex for about two years, but I just wasn't ready," but looking at the dildo and plug she's preparing—she's ready now. When Jack (Rob Piper) joins her, there is lengthy foreplay before they bring in the plug, which is inserted slowly, followed by Piper's cock, which she eases onto in reverse cowgirl so she can control the penetration. The whole scene, lasting more than 30 minutes, places an emphasis on going deliberately.

Next up, Leya Falcon doms Chad Diamond, playfully smiling as he worships her feet, ass and pussy before he outfits her with a large jet black strap-on, sucking it before she pegs him. Berlyn Toy illustrates cum-eating in a scene with Brad Newman where she takes the facial and fingers it into her mouth, and then sucks out every last drop. Finally, Elena Koshka and Codey Steele illustrate marathon sex, as she says in voice-over, "He makes me insatiable, and it becomes a game of who can fuck the longest." There's some light bondage here, with blindfolds and restraints, and exotic positions like piledriver, but the idea is still instructive.

The deliberate pace set by writer Melissa Monet and delivered by director Skye Blue, matched with well-shot images by Hank Hoffman and Joel Sinclair, present the material in a non-confrontational, unthreatening way.