The concept is a good one from the marketing standpoint: assemble a cast of the hottest male stars from straight adult films and have them strut their stuff for a gay audience. The execution is equally strong: superb videography, a variety of settings, and situations that capture the personalities of the straight actors.
So what are my reservations? The first, I admit, is subjective: I simply can't get all hot and bothered over straight men, no matter how attractive they may be. But the second seems to me an objective, level-headed criticism: with the exception of Randy Spears and Sean Michaels, these guys seem to be ill at ease without a female partner at hand. T.T. Boy and Derek Lane look like fish out of water, while Cal Jammer and Lex Baldwin overcompensate with almost parodic posturing and comical attempts to be "sexy". But Spears and Michaels create quite a bit of erotic heat, suggesting that both men enjoy being admired by viewers of either gender. In my admittedly limited opinion, they are the true male superstars of the straight industry, and for that I give them all due credit.